Showing posts with label Books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Books. Show all posts

Sunday, May 4, 2008

Book Review: "The Greatest Game Ever Played" by Mark Frost

The Greatest Game Ever Played: Harry Vardon, Francis Ouimet, and the Birth of Modern Golf

by Mark Frost

Originally published: November 2002
Paperback: 496 pages

Almost everyone with an addiction to the game of golf has heard of "The Greatest Game Ever Played". Some are familiar with the Disney movie, while others know it as the book by Twin Peaks co-creator and composer Mark Frost. Either way, unless you have delved into its meaty pages, you are probably under the impression that "The Greatest Game Ever Played" is the tale of a single, albeit legendary, golf tournament between an unknown amateur named Francis Ouimet and professional titan Harry Vardon at the 1913 U.S. Open.

It is.

And it is not.

While the 1913 U.S. Open match between Ouimet and Vardon provided Frost with the central framework for the book and it's gripping climax, the truer description of the book's content is contained in its subtitle: "Harry Vardon, Francis Ouimet, and the Birth of Modern Golf". For Frost, the story of Ouimet, Vardon, Ray, and the other cast of characters is, in large part, a mechanism through which he was able to re-create the history of the game from inception through it's acceptance in America. Frost starts his story several years before the epic duel between Vardon and Ouimet in 1913 and describes the people, the development of the equipment, the disparate treatment of professional versus amateur golfers, and everything in between.

If golf was a college history course, "The Greatest Game Ever Played" would be the textbook for the period of creation of tournament golf in Scotland through wide acceptance in America. At times, the shear weight of the detail packed into the text by Frost almost capsizes the central story of the book. Almost . . . but not quite.

Eventually, Frost hits his stride, moves away from a history book mentality, and he does an excellent job of telling the story of the 1913 U.S. Open. And what a story it is.

The Greatest Game Ever Played is not a book for the casual golf historian. It is a deep, rich, time consuming, and occasionally frustrating look at the birth of modern tournament golf. But like any difficult task worth doing, it is a rewarding experience and one not to be overlooked by any true fan of the history of the game.







Thursday, April 17, 2008

Book Review: "Who's Your Caddy?" by Rick Reilly

"Who's Your Caddy?: Looping for the Great, Near Great, and Reprobates of Golf"

by Rick Reilly


Originally published: May 2003
Paperback: 272 pages



In "Who's Your Caddy?: Looping for the Great, Near Great, and Reprobates of Golf", Sports Illustrated columnist Rick Reilly chronicles his attempts at caddying for PGA and LPGA players, celebrities, and high stakes gamblers. Reilly, with no prior caddying experience, relates his journey from terrible novice caddy to terrible somewhat-experienced caddy in his signature lighthearted and humorous style. Each chapter of "Who's Your Caddy?" is comprised of a story about Reilly's experience caddying for a specific golfer, including such notables as John Daly, David Duval, Donald Trump, and Bob Newhart. In addition to the narrative of the loop itself, Reilly provides just enough biographical and background information in each chapter so that even a non-golfer can understand the context of each individual story.

"Who's Your Caddy?" is by no means an important piece of golf literature in the same category of works such as "The Greatest Game Ever Played" by Mark Frost. It is, however, an extremely humorous and occasionally informative look at one of the often overlooked and important facets of the game - the caddy. I enjoyed the chapter on the LPGA in particular. However, I will refrain from re-telling any of the anecdotes in order to avoid spoiling the fun. And thanks to Reilly's witty storytelling skills, there is fun to be had. (On the other hand, I can't even look at John Daly in the Winn Grips commercials after the "bratwurst" story . . . [shiver!] )

The inspiring chapter on Casey Martin, current University of Oregon head golf coach and former Supreme Court litigant in a landmark case that granted him the right to use a golf cart in PGA tour events under the "American's with Disabilities Act of 1990", is worth reading for its important content. Even if you've already formed an opinion on whether Martin's lengthy fight with the PGA Tour was shameful, heroic, or much ado about nothing, Reilly's descriptions of the effects of Martin's disability warrant consideration before assessing the merits of Martin's claims.

"Who's Your Caddy?" is one of my favorite golf-related books, and it is a quick and easy read even for golfers not normally inclined to read anything longer than a scorecard or the beer menu at the 19th hole. Pick it up.